I'm about four months into my effort to go natural with my makeup and skincare and I've found a number of products that are working nicely for me. Early on, I got sucked into this whole
“Going Natural" project and was researching and ordering and trying new products left and right, but— as I shared in
this post— the appeal wore off. I've reverted back to my old habits, which is to find a handful of (natural) products that I can rely on, perhaps only making a few color changes by season. Many days I've been going without makeup all together; I think a
good skin-care regimen and a healthy diet have done a lot for making me comfortable in my skin, au naturale.
There is a whole fun world of natural makeup out there, but I can safely say this will likely be my last
“Going Natural" post.
Maybe I'll share my updated makeup favorites in the fall when I move away from coral/pinks to berry/plum shades but we shall see. I have too many other interests that are more worthy of my time, attention, and money; my face is
so not my hobby :) I understand why people find makeup fun, but for me it's just not the way I prefer to take care of myself or treat myself, and a constant desire for new products generally goes against my simple and minimalist approach to life. I'm okay being your plain-faced friend with the messy hair and unpolished nails, who is always wearing those dirty old trail shoes and is far more comfortable in a bookstore or hiking in the woods than in Sephora (though I can't be the only one who is completely terrified/intimidated by Sephora,
right?).
Before I dive into the products I've been turning to, I'd like to add a caveat that many natural beauty enthusiasts don't really consider Tarte to be a
real natural brand. Tarte still uses a fair amount of toxins in their products that are rated as cautionary on
EWG's Cosmetic Database. However, I've decided that I'm comfortable using their products, especially since I don't wear makeup everyday. It's nice to have the option of popping into Ulta to see Tarte products in person. Most natural makeup has to be ordered online since it isn't available in stores, and ordering sight-unseen doesn't always work out that well. For me, Tarte is a nice compromise between conventional/drugstore makeup and the natural products only available online. (FYI: if you sign up for emails from Tarte, you can get 20% off your first order from their website.)
Natural products I'm loving (clockwise from top left)
* Tarte blush in Blissful: A nice matte coral-peachy blush. I love the color and it seems to look nice on my skin.
However... Tarte blushes are known for being pigmented and long-lasting, and yet I still have a very hard time transferring the color onto my cheeks. I've tried a variety of brushes and nothing makes a difference. Even when I try and swatch the color on my arm with my finger, hardly any color transfers from my finger to my forearm. I don't get it. I have had this problem with some other pressed blushes too though— maybe it's my skin type?
* Physician's Formula Organic Wear CC Cream: This has been my go-to foundation. I find that the coverage is very good with a nice dewy finish. It's easy to blend and builds up nicely if needed.
* RMS Beauty Lip Shine in Sublime: This is a bright cool-toned pink potted lip gloss that borders on acid pink in the pot but applies like a sheer bubblegum that can be built up. I love the clean ingredients and how smooth it feels on my lips. This is my only RMS product so far, and I will be getting more.
* Zuzu Luxe Liquid Eyeliner: This came up in the green beauty world over and over again as the best natural liquid liner. It does the job quite well for me, and I like it much better than the Maybelline liquid liner I used to use. I bought mine on Amazon.
* Silk Naturals blush in Poppy (sample): This is a loose mineral powder blush, and the matte coral color is slightly more orange than the Tarte Blissful. As I mentioned above, I seem to have issues with pressed blush, but this loose powder is very pigmented and I've really enjoyed the sample. Unfortunately, aside from this product and the
Jane lipstick, I didn't love anything else I tried from Silk Naturals. On the plus side, all of their products are fairly cheap--but so is their packaging :(
* Vapour Organics Illusionist Concealer (recommended with reservations): I find this concealer stick to be similar to the
Maybelline Dream Lumi Touch concealer I had been using before. This is a cream stick rather than a liquid, but the luminescent effect is very similar. I found the coverage to be good for the under-eye area, and it has a nice light herbal smell. My reservation for this product is that the packaging completely fell apart the second time I used it— the glue holding down the inner tube seems to have melted or dissolved. I do tend to blame this on the online shop I bought it from (who shall remain nameless) rather than Vapour Organics, as that order was a disaster. My Pai Rosehip Oil leaked during shipping, and while I
don't think it leaked on the other products, there is a small chance that some of the oil could have caused the glue to come unstuck. But the product itself I recommend.
* Tarte Lipsurgence Skintuitive Lip Tint in Energy (deluxe sample): I have a hard time considering this a true natural makeup product, given that it is one of those lip products that adjusts to your body pH and transforms into your perfect pink lip shade. Something about that just seems like sorcery. But I absolutely love it anyways, and I'll probably put the full size on my wishlist when the sample is gone. The shade it becomes on my lips is really nice, a sheer berry.
* Honeybee Gardens Pressed Mineral Powder Foundation: This is another favorite product in the green beauty world, and an affordable one at that (especially if you buy it
without the compact from Vitacost). I use this on occasion to set my liquid foundation. I have also used it on its own as a mineral foundation, but I have to be very moisturized first since I have dry skin and I want to avoid looking cakey.
Everything else I've tried, with some mini-reviews
* Physician's Formula Organic Wear Mascara: This is an okay mascara, but sometimes flakes and I don't like how my eyelashes feel tacky the entire time I'm wearing it.
* Silk Naturals loose mineral eyeshadow (various shades): Overall,
these were a total let-down. I found them messy and lacking
pigmentation. The shadows containing glitter were very chunky. I might
try to turn them into pressed eyeshadow using a
Youtube tutorial, but
that seems like a lot of work.
* Silk Naturals Stick Em Eyeshadow Enhancer: I don't notice a difference whether I wear this or not. It's quite possible I just don't know how to apply loose eyeshadow properly.
* Silk Naturals Slick Stick in Mirage: I was searching for a nude lipcolor, but this one is a little too
“bruise colored" on me. I think I wanted
Cultured but ordered the wrong one :(
* Tarte Cheek Stain in Flush: Smells delicious, adds a very natural flush to the cheeks. Some people complain about blending these gel blushes, but I haven't had trouble. A little goes a long way. Very expensive for the size of the product, though.
* Ilia Tinted Lip Conditioner in Arabian Nights: I love this deep berry shade, but it's more of a winter color. I expected the Lip Conditioner formula to be balmier to apply, but it's kind of stiff.
* 100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Foundation: I like the texture and application, but I bought a shade too dark and the site I ordered from (the unnamed online shop mentioned above) doesn't offer exchanges (note: if you order from the 100% Pure website, they offer free exchanges). I'll be saving this for mid-summer and hopefully will be tan enough for it.
* Tarte Bow-to-Go holiday set containing 4 Lipsurgence, 1 eyeshadow palette, Lights Camera Lashes mascara, and two Smolder Eyes: I got this set on clearance on Tarte's site for just over $35— SUCH a steal! I like the palette, but haven't had the chance to use the rest of the products yet.
A few things I'm still interested in
*
RMS Living Luminizer
*
Dr. Hauschka mascara
* A cream bronze eyeshadow similar to my go-to Maybelline Color Tattoo in Bad to the Bronze, maybe something from
100% Pure or
RMS Beauty? Lots of reviews mention creasing for these though, so I might just stick with the Maybelline as it is such a favorite of mine.
* A natural pencil eyeliner
* A natural sunscreen for the days I want to go without foundation (which has SPF in it)